SPS-201 Refractive Outcomes II | ASCRS
April 25-28, 2025 | Los Angeles, CA

2025 ASCRS Annual Meeting

SPS-201
Refractive Outcomes II 

Moderator
Edward E. Manche, MD, ABO
Panelists
Sara K Sella, MD
Pooja Khamar, MD, PhD

Viewing Papers
Expand a paper title to the right to view the paper abstract and authors. Use the video link to jump to that poster in the session.

Novel Shape, Energy and Spots: Outcomes with a New Lenticule Extraction Platform (Shroff)

Authors

Presenting Author
Rushad C. Shroff, MS

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To analyze refractive outcomes, contrast sensitivity, aberrations and tear film metrics using the ELITA Femtosecond platform for lenticule extraction (Johnson & Johnson, Inc) in the treatment of myopia. Setting: Tertairy Eye care cetre in North India

Methods
150 eyes of 75 patients who underwent Lenticule extraction using the ELITA platform (Johnson & Johnson) were included in this prospective interventional study. The Pentacam HR (Oculus Optikger�te GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany) and itrace (Tracey Technologies Corp., Houston, TX, USA) were used to measure the corneal and total aberrations. Tear film metrics were measured using the Keratograph (Oculus Optikger�te GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany)and Lipiview device (TearScience Inc., Morrisville, NC, USA) .Refractive visual outcomes were also studied at 1 month and 3 months post surgery

Results
Lenticule Extraction with the ELITA femtosecond laser Platform was found to be accurate, safe and effective. The total root mean square (RMS) and RMS of lower order aberrations did not show significant change after the procedure (P =0.65). None of the study subjects lost lines of Corrected Distance visual Acuity. 96 % eyes attained a UDVA of 20/20 or better. 90 percent eyes were within 1 D of targeted spherical and cylindrical correction. There was no significant change in MTF (P=0.23) demonstrating good preservation of contrast sensitivity. Non invasive BUT and Lipid layer thickness did not show significant deterioration post procedure. No adverse effect on the ocular surface was noted

Conclusion
Lenticule Extraction with the ELITA femtosecond laser Platform was found to be accurate, safe and effective with no significant deterioration in quality of vision as well as tear film metrics.

Evaluation of Refractive Outcomes and Higher-Order Aberrations after Implantable Collamer Lens Placement with a Central Port Design (Ye)

Authors

Presenting Author
Emily Y Ye, MD, MS
Co-Authors
Karolinne Rocha MD, PhD, Aline Hagui MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To evaluate refractive outcomes and changes in higher-order aberrations induced by implantable collamer lens placement with a central port design.

Methods
This retrospective study included healthy eyes undergoing surgery for implantable collamer lens (EVO ICL, STAAR Surgical) placement to correct myopia with or without astigmatism between December 2023 and August 2024. Horizontal corneal white to white (WTW) diameter was measured using scheimpflug tomography, swept-source OCT-based biometer (IOL master 700), and digital calipers. Manifest refraction spherical equivalent (MRSE), corrected and uncorrected distance visual acuity (CDVA, UDVA) were measured preoperatively and post-operatively. Higher-order aberrations were measured using a combined Scheimpflug and Hartman-Shack device (Pentacam Wave). Statistical analysis was performed with SPSS.

Results
13 eyes of 7 patients were included with average age of 35.29 � 5.07 years at time of surgery. Average uncorrected distance visual acuity (UDVA) post-operatively was 0.003 � 0.07 (logMAR). There was a statistically significant decrease in post-operative spherical aberrations for an optical zone of 5 mm (mean difference 0.032, P= 0.015, paired t-test) as well as a statistically significant post-operative decrease in coma aberrations for an optical zone of 5 mm (mean difference 0.06, P= 0.007, paired t-test). There were no statistically significant differences in post-operative change for trefoil aberrations, or coma and spherical aberrations at 3 mm optical zone.

Conclusion
A decrease in higher order aberrations were found for spherical and coma aberrations post-operatively. However, the study is still limited to small sample size. Overall, all patients included in the study achieved excellent visual outcomes.

Visual and Refractive Outcomes Following Laser Blended Vision with Non-Linear Aspheric Micro-Anisometropia (PRESBYOND) (Varman)

Authors

Presenting Author
Aadithreya Varman, MS
Co-Authors
Arulmozhi Varman MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
Purpose: To evaluate the visual outcomes of Presbyond laser blended vision for the correction of ametropia with Presbyopia

Methods
Study design:Prospective Inclusion criteria :Myopia : -0.5 Ds to -7.00 Ds , Hyperopia: +0.5 Ds to +4.00 Ds , Clear lens ,No other ocular comorbidity ( Diabetic retinopathy , glaucoma , cataract) A total of 70 patients were included. 40 Hyperopic and 30 Myopic with BCVA pf 20/20 in both eyes. Refraction was recorded meticulously by performing manual cycloplegic refraction, followed by confirmative subjective refraction/ Depending upon the acceptance, patients either received a near add of +1.50 or +1.25 in the non dominant eye The VISUMAX 800 platform was used for the creation of flap The Mel-90 excimer platform was used for the ablation using the PRESBYOND algorithm

Results
All eyes in the myopia group achieved a postoperative CDVA of 20/25 or better. At 1 month, 79.2% of myopic eyes showed no change in Snellen lines of CDVA and 20.8% of myopic eyes improved one line. No eyes lost two or more lines of CDVA. After hyperopia treatment, all eyes achieved CDVA of 20/25 or better. 87.5% of eyes maintained the preoperative CDVA, whereas one eye gained one line and one eye lost one line . No eyes lost two or more lines CDVA.. A statistically significant shift in spherical aberration was observed in both the myopia and hyperopia groups in opposite directions.

Conclusion
Presbyond laser blended vision was found to be a safe and effective procedure for the treatment of Presbyopia with Myopia/hyperopia. Patient reported outcomes were satisfactory with no reported complaints on steroacuity or cross blur due to the micro anisometropia

Over High Refractive Errors Are Tragedy or Any Solutions; Phakic IOL Combined with Lasik Surgery (Yusupov)

Authors

Presenting Author
Azamat F. Yusupov, MD
Co-Authors
Nozim Zaynutdinov MD, Muyassar Karimova MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To assess clinical outcomes after phakic IOL implantation combined with laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis in patients with over high refractive errors.

Methods
In this retrospective, observational study, 41 eyes of 22 patients had been investigated after ICL implantation and laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) surgery. The main clinical outcomes of this study were uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA), best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), ICL vault, intraocular pressure (IOP), keratometric value and central corneal thickness (CCT). All postoperative outcomes had been evaluated at 1 day, 1 week, 1, 3 and 6 months in postoperative period. The main indications for LASIK surgery in eyes were residual refractive outcomes after ICL implantation.

Results
Totally 41 eyes of 22 patients with over high refractive errors had underwent ICL implantation and Trans Epi method of LASIK surgery from 2020 to 2023. The mean age of patients was 26.25�2.75. The mean preop manifest spherical equivalent was -17.25�2.75 D and manifest cylinder was -2.75�0.50 D respectively (p?0.001) and spherical refractive measures reduced to -0.5�0.25 D and cylinder measures reduced to -0.5�0.15 D postoperatively. After ICL implantation, the mean residual spherical equivalent was -2.5�0.75 D and corrected with using Trans Epi Lasik surgery on 1st month of postop period. The mean preoperative CCT value was 456�37 �m. The mean postop CCT was 408�23 �m respectively (p?0.001).

Conclusion
Visian ICL implantation is a safe, effective and alternative refractive surgery for correction of over high refractive errors. Residual spheric equivalent might be corrected with using Trans Epi method of LASIK surgery. This method is safe and could be used to reach high postop visual results.

Clinical Outcomes after Phakic IOL Implantation in High Myopic Patients with Narrow Anterior Chamber Depth (Yusupov)

Authors

Presenting Author
Azamat F. Yusupov, MD
Co-Authors
Nozim Zaynutdinov MD, Muyassar Karimova MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To evaluate clinical outcomes after ICL implantation in high myopic patients with narrow anterior chamber depth.

Methods
In this retrospective and observational study, we aimed to evaluate the results of 32 high myopic eyes of 21 patients who had been undergone ICL implantation from 2020 to 2024. In all stages of investigation, the main clinical outcomes of this study were uncorrected visual acuity, best corrected visual acuity, ICL vault, intraocular pressure, anterior chamber depth and development of any kind postoperative complications. Clinical outcomes have been evaluated at 1 day, 1 week, 1,3 and 12 months in postoperative period. Especially, we gave an attention to the anterior chamber depth and intraocular pressure after phakic IOL implantation during postoperative follow-up period.

Results
The mean age of 21 patients was 26.21�3.56. Ten men (47.6%) and eleven (52.4%) were women patients. The mean preoperative manifest spherical equivalent was -11.50�3.72 D and manifest cylinder was -1.25�0.3 D, which postoperative spherical refractive measures reduced to -0.5�0.25 D and cylinder measures reduced to -0.5�0.12 D respectively (p?0.001). The mean IOP was 13.7�1.45 mmHg preoperatively. The mean IOP has changed until 15.44�1.76 mmHg during twelve months in postoperative period. Preoperatively the mean anterior chamber depth was 2.43�0.15 mm. The mean anterior chamber depth was 2.18�0.17 mm and the mean ICL vault was 124�46 �m. Any complications weren`t revealed in postop period.

Conclusion
ICL implantation is safe, effective and alternative method of refractive surgery. Even anterior chamber depth is less than required parameters; surgeon could implant ICL and get best postop results. However, in these cases all patients should be accurately prepared for planned surgery and must be followed up periodically IOP and ICL vault.

Visual and Refractive Outcomes in 1500 Eyes Treated with Lenticule Extraction on a New Platform for Correcting Myopia and Myopic Astigmatism (Varman)

Authors

Presenting Author
Aadithreya Varman, MS
Co-Authors
Arulmozhi Varman MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
Purpose: To evaluate the visual outcomes of keratorefractive lenticule extraction using a new platform with semi-automated cyclotorsion control and treatment centration assistant for the treatment of myopia and myopic astigmatism

Methods
Methods: This was an prospective study of consecutive eyes treated by SMILE with the VISUMAX 800 femtosecond laser at a private practice in Chennai ,India between June 2022 and December 2024. Inclusion criteria were myopia between up to -10D and astigmatism between 1.5D and 5D. Patients were treated with SMILE on VISUMAX 800 using Oculign and Centralign software aids for cyclotorsion control and treatment centration respectively. Post operative outcomes are reported at the 3 month mark and will include the standard 9 graphs reporting safety and efficacy of treatment.Aberrometry data from pre and post op visits will be compared to further elucidate any benefit of the software assistants

Results
Normality of the data was checked using Shapiro-Wilk�s test. Data was collected from 1500 eyes that underwent routine lenticule extraction. The mean attempted spherical equivalent was -4.11�1.94 D At the 3-month postoperative visit, UDVA was 20/20 or better in 94% of eyes compared to 100% with a preoperative CDVA of 20/20 or better. Accuracy of the SEQ showed that 92.5% of eyes were within �0.50 D and 98.7% were within �1.00 D of intended target. Cylinder analysis showed that 91.9% of eyes had ? 0.50 D of refractive astigmatism. No eyes lost two or more lines of CDVA.

Conclusion
KLEX on Visumax 800 is a safe and effective procedure for the treatment of myopia and astigmatism. The intraoperative cyclotorsion compensation offered by the VM 800 platform allows for accurate correction of astigmatism. The centration aids which help align the treatment zone on the corneal vertex assist in accurate treatment centration/

Comparison of Visual Outcomes of Klex before and after Implementing a Nomogram from a New Nomogram Generation Software Tool (Doane)

Authors

Presenting Author
John F. Doane, MD, ABO

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To report and compare the refractive and visual outcomes of small-incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) for myopia and myopic astigmatism using the VisuMax femtosecond laser (Carl Zeiss Meditec) before and after implementing a VISULYZE (Carl Zeiss Meditec) generated treatment nomogram.

Methods
This was a retrospective, single site clinical study evaluating eyes that underwent routine SMILE for myopia and myopic astigmatism by one experienced surgeon between August 2023 and December 2023. Inclusion criteria were patients 18 years or older with sphere from -1.00 to -10.00D, cylinder up to 3.00D, a preoperative CDVA of ?20/25 Snellen, and completed a 1-month postoperative visit. Preoperative, operative, and postoperative data was collected, and standard outcomes analysis was performed.

Results
A total of 206 eyes met the inclusion criteria; 109 eyes treated before the nomogram (BV group) and the first 97 eyes treated after implementing the nomogram (AV group). Mean attempted SEQ was -3.82�1.90 (-0.88 to -9.13D) in the BV group and 3.85�1.8 ( 0.75 to -8.63D) in the AV group. Postop SEQ was within �0.50D in 91.7% of eyes in the BV group and 97.9% of eyes in the AV group. UDVA was 20/20 or better in 85% of eyes in the BV group 90% of eyes in the AV group. Astigmatism analysis showed 90.8% of eyes in the BV group and 93.8% of eyes in the AV group had ?0.50 of postop refractive cylinder

Conclusion
Implementation of a VISULYZE generated treatment nomogram improved the refractive accuracy of the treatment, resulting in better visual outcomes compared to eyes treated before the new nomogram was in use. Further, large population studies are needed to confirm these initial results

Patient-Reported Outcomes with LASIK Following a New Ray Tracing-Based Treatment Algorithm with an Individualized Ablation Profile (Solomon)

Authors

Presenting Author
Kerry D. Solomon, MD
Co-Authors
Jeffrey Whitman MD, Stephen Wexler MD, Francis Price MD, Ronald Krueger MSE, MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To evaluate patient-reported outcomes of ray tracing�based LASIK surgery for the correction of myopia in eyes with and without astigmatism

Methods
Included were patients ?21 years-old with myopia ??11.0 D, with or without astigmatism ??4.5 D. For each eye, a virtual 3D model and individualized ablation profile was developed using data collected from the InnovEyes� Sightmap and processed by the wavelight plus ray-tracing algorithm. Factors including visual and dry eye symptoms, satisfaction with treatment, visual symptoms (double images, halos, glare, and starbursts), and ocular surface disease index (OSDI) were assessed via Patient-Reported Outcomes With LASIK (PROWL) questionnaire, administered via electronic clinical outcome assessment tablets at study visits.

Results
Of 168 patients (336 eyes) enrolled, 161 patients (322 eyes) completed the study. Reports of visual symptoms decreased postoperatively compared to preoperatively, with 97.5% of subjects satisfied with their vision. 91.4% of subjects reported no longer using glasses or contact lenses at 12 months. Mean OSDI scores showed a reduction in dry eye symptoms by -6.48 at 3 months and remained stable at 12 months.

Conclusion
PROWL data of wavelight plus LASIK treatment correcting myopia in individuals with and without astigmatism demonstrated good patient-reported symptoms and satisfaction with the procedure.

Refractive Outcomes after SMILE with the Visumax 800 from a User with No Previous Klex Experience (Dell)

Authors

Presenting Author
Steven J. Dell, MD, ABO

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To report the outcomes of SMILE for myopia and myopic astigmatism using the VISUMAX 800 femtosecond laser (Carl Zeiss Meditec) during the learning curve of a new SMILE surgeon.

Methods
This is a retrospective analysis of the first 50 consecutive eyes treated with SMILE for myopia and myopic astigmatism at Dell Laser Consultants, Austin, TX from June 2024 to Dec 2024. Inclusion criteria are patients 21 years of age with sphere from -1.00 to -10.00D, cylinder up to 3.00D, and will have completed at least a 1-month postoperative visit. Preoperative, operative, and postoperative data including UDVA, manifest refraction, and CDVA will be collected from eyes that meet the inclusion criteria. Standard outcomes analysis will be performed.

Results
Outcomes reported will be based on the standard nine graphs for reporting refractive surgery including: mean attempted SEQ, postoperative SEQ within 0.50D and within 1.00D, attempted vs achieved SEQ, cumulative percentage of eyes with UDVA 20/20 or better and 20/25 or better, change in postoperative CDVA compared to preoperative CDVA, and additional astigmatism analysis including percentage of eyes with a postoperative refractive cylinder ?0.50D and ?1.00D, SIA vs TIA, and angle of error distribution.

Conclusion
A summary of the outcomes will be provided, and any key take away messages from the learning curve experience with the VISUMAX 800 for a new SMILE surgeon will be discussed.

Assessing the Impact of Surgically Induced Astigmatism on Outcomes of Toric Evo ICL Implantation (Navas Villar)

Authors

Presenting Author
Erik A Navas Villar, MD
Co-Authors
Erick Navarro MD, Ivonne Curiel Arce MD, Arturo Chayet MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To evaluate the effect of surgically induced astigmatism (SIA) on refractive outcomes in patients undergoing toric EVO Visian Implantable Collamer Lens (ICL) implantation by STAAR Surgical.

Methods
One - year, non - randomized, prospective study of 26 eyes myopic eyes of 15 patients were SIA was assessed with the implantation of a toric EVO Visian Implantable Collamer Lens (ICL) implantation by STAAR Surgical. ICL power calculations were performed using the manufacturer�s (STAAR Surgical Company) online calculation tool. ICL sizing was based on the corneal horizontal white-to-white (WTW) distance, measured with the Anterion (Heidelberg, Germany). All corneal incisions were made temporally using a 2.8 mm clear corneal approach, with all procedures performed by the same experienced surgeon. Patients underwent two evaluations: one 24 hours post-surgery and another 6 weeks later.

Results
Average age was 30 years � 6.4. Using a 2.8 temporal clear corneal incision the SIA average was 0.44 D � 0.23 with the rule. Predicted refractive cylinder was -0.40 D @ 171� and the obtained refractive cylinder was -0.50 @ 153�. A double angle plot graph would be summitted.

Conclusion
The ICL online formula of STAAR surgical needs to be updated to include the SIA factor and by this means enhance refractive results in this group of patients. What

Is a Postoperative Cornea Flatter Than 34D Associated with Worse Outcomes? (Mimouni)

Authors

Presenting Author
Michael Mimouni, MD
Co-Authors
Waseem Nasser MD, PhD, Adir Sommer MD, Margarita Safir MD, Dror Ben Ephraim Noyman MD, BSc, Gur Munzer BA, Eyal Cohen MD, Tzahi Sela BScOptom, Igor Kaiserman MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
To compare the postoperative outcomes of patients who underwent myopic photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) with a postoperative corneal curvature below 34 diopters (D) versus those with a curvature above 34 D.

Methods
This retrospective study included 17,019 eyes that underwent myopic PRK at Care Vision Laser Centers with 183 eyes (1.08%) classified as having a flat postoperative cornea (average keratometry <34 d).="" baseline="" and="" intraoperative="" characteristics="" were="" compared="" between="" the="" flat="" cornea="" group="" and="" a="" control="" group="" (average="" keratometry="" 4="" d).="" postoperative="" outcomes,="" including="" uncorrected="" visual="" acuity="" (ucva),="" spherical="" equivalent="" (seq),="" and="" other="" refractive="" and="" visual="" parameters,="" were="" analyzed="" both="" before="" and="" after="" adjusting="" for="" differences="" in="" baseline="" and="" intraoperative="">

Results
The flat cornea group had greater preoperative myopia (SEQ: -10.2�2.3 D vs. -4.9�2.6 D, p<0.001), and="" exhibited="" thicker="" minimal="" corneal="" thickness="" (540.7�33.5="" �m="" vs.="" 530.2�33.6="" �m,=""><0.001). intraoperatively,="" they="" received="" a="" higher="" spherical="" correction="" (8.9�1.5="" d="" vs.="" 4.8�2.2="" d,=""><0.001) and="" deeper="" maximum="" ablation="" depth="" (131.7�17.2="" �m="" vs.="" 82.8�36.2="" �m,=""><0.001). unadjusted="" postoperative="" outcomes="" indicated="" worse="" ucva="" (logmar:="" 0.06�0.11="" vs.="" 0.03�0.07,=""><0.001). after="" adjusting="" for="" baseline="" and="" intraoperative="" differences,="" no="" significant="" differences="" were="" observed="" in="" ucva="" (logmar:="" 0.03="" vs.="" 0.03,="" p="1.00)" or="" other="" key="" refractive="" outcomes="" between="" the="">

Conclusion
Although patients with flat postoperative corneas (34D) had worse postoperative visual outcomes, these differences were not significant after adjusting for baseline and intraoperative variables. It is probable that inferior outcomes in this group is the result of an aggressive treatment rather than an excessively flattened cornea.

Comparative Analysis of Ease of Lenticule Removal and Visual Outcomes across Different Optical Zones with the Elita System (Gabric)

Authors

Presenting Author
Ivan Gabric, MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
JJSV has developed a new femtosecond laser (aka ELITA). This clinical trial evaluated the ease of lenticule removal and visual outcomes for myopic refractive correction with or without astigmatism, across various optical zones. Results are presented up to 3-months post-operatively.

Methods
Fifty myopic eyes were treated using the ELITA system, with varying optical zone (OZ) sizes: 7 eyes with 6.0 mm OZ, 12 with 6.5 mm OZ, 9 with 6.7 mm OZ and 22 with 7.0 mm OZ. Main outcomes included an assessment of ease of lenticule removal, uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA), and best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) across different optical zones (6.0, 6.5, 6.7 and 7.0 mm), evaluated up to the 3 month follow-up visit

Results
50 eyes at 1D and 1W post op, 48 at 1M and 42 at 3M across different optical zones were analyzed. Surgeons reported 93% favorable lenticule removal (no/mild dissection) with 13.3%, 20%, 20% and 40% from 6.0, 6.5, 6.7 and 7.0 OZ respectively. Moderate dissection was reported in 2.2% for OZs of 6.0, 6.5 and 7.0 mm, and no cases of difficult dissection were reported. UCVA of 20/20 or better by OZ was: 1W - 74% for 6.0 OZ, 92% for6.5 OZ, 92% for 6.7 OZ, and 73% for7.0 OZ; and at 3M - 93% in 6.0 OZ, 100% in 6.5 OZ, 89% in 6.7 OZ, and 94% in 7.0 OZ. BCVA of 20/20 or better was achieved in 100% of eyes at the 3M f/u

Conclusion
These results demonstrate that ease of lenticule removal is successfully achieved across multiple optical zones and excellent visual outcomes are achieved with the new ELITA femtosecond laser, concluding that the ELITA femtosecond laser effectively generates lenticules with diverse optical zones

Evaluation of a New Femtosecond Laser for Corneal Flap Creation (Shetty)

Authors

Presenting Author
Rohit Shetty, FRCS
Co-Authors
Pooja Khamar MD, PhD, Matthias Maus MD

Paper Abstract

Purpose
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the safety and performance of a new femtosecond laser (Ultra-short wavelength) for creation of corneal flaps for LASIK.

Methods
This was a prospective, interventional, nonrandomized, open label, multicenter, single arm, single eye study. Subjects?18 years-old undergoing routine myopia correcting refractive surgery underwent flap creation with the Ultra-short wavelength laser prior to LASIK. Efficacy and safety were evaluated for up to six months.

Results
Fifty-nine subjects were treated and completed the study. The mean (SD) difference between the achieved average central flap thickness and intended flap thickness at 1 month postoperative was -0.73 (11.984) �m (90% CI [-3.34, 1.87]). Postoperative UCDVA and MRSE demonstrated favorable visual outcomes from all eyes with mean UCDVA of -0.071 logMAR and MRSE of -0.0948 D at 6 months. There were no intraoperative or postoperative ocular AEs related to flap creation or treatment. No serious AEs or ADEs were reported.

Conclusion
Overall, the Ultra-short wavelength Femtosecond Laser demonstrated the ability to accurately and safely cut corneal flaps as part of myopia correcting LASIK procedures.

This content is only available to 2025 ASCRS Annual Meeting physician registrants

To log in, click the teal "Login" button in the upper right-hand corner of this page. If you are logged in but still do not have access, please check your 2025 Annual Meeting registration.